I recommend these JCW fobs! They are made from metal and have a nice heft, feel, fit, and finish. HOWEVER, the wonderful paint job almost completely rubs off after just a few months of carrying in a pocket or purse from rubbing against coins and other pocket items. I bought a second pair and sprayed them with 5 coats of clear gloss paint. They are holding up much better. If you buy these, coat them with clear paint or you will be sorry!